Saturday, July 19, 2008

Exiles and the real Hopkins

Today I caught up with InsideCatholic's discussion of Exiles, which went on for thirteen pages and included Ron Hansen's own comments at the end! Having read the whole thing, I have decided to write a more specific review of the novel than I planned. It will be from my perspective as a student of Hopkins.

I have been in love with Hopkins' poetry since I was 15, and I managed to write a Classics thesis on his Latin poetry. So naturally I ordered Exiles before it was even published. I wasn't sure what to expect, but as I read, I began to understand that Exiles is a novelized biography, not quite a novel. Hansen imposed some very strict limits on his invention, which he summarizes here:
Tackling the subject, various boundaries and limits were ethically imposed. I would never be at variance with the history, insofar as I could determine it. I sought to give life and personality to Gerard M. Hopkins, S.J., while avoiding the harmful and presumptuous conclusion that I had figured him out, which is something I cannot claim for either my family or friends.
This is admirable. There are so many people who love to fill in the blanks in Hopkins' biography with homosexual crushes on the one hand and the dark night of the soul on the other, things which no one really knows and probably never will. Hansen succeeds as a biographer in areas where Norman White and Robert Martin fall short. He refuses to interpret what is ambiguous and unsaid, but he takes the known events of Hopkins' life and discerns an order to them where other biographies find a dull and disorderly progression of largely wasted years, crowned by a meaningless death. Hansen uses the story of the five nuns on the Deutschland to bring out the hidden shape of Hopkins' life.

And yet... this wasn't the only road he could have taken. He could have fashioned a character called "Hopkins" who would fit within the limits of the primary sources, and yet be created from all the imaginative resources at a novelist's command. Just as there is the real Virgil, so mysterious with his reticent biography, and then the "Virgil" of Dante or Hermann Broch - so Ron Hansen could have created his own Hopkins and represented a fascinating inner life, from the inside. In some ways he can't help doing this already. "Why pray?" asks Hopkins when asked why he is writing a poem that he thinks few will want to read. These are not Hopkins' own words. And then there is Hopkins' imagined last confession, where he confesses shutting off the grace of poetic inspiration. Both of these invented scenes reconcile prayer and poetry to a degree which the real Hopkins probably didn't. It's difficult to call them "inaccurate," but they do go a little beyond the explicit facts. In an interview on NPR, Hansen was asked how he reconciles his own belief that writing can be a form of prayer with Hopkins' conflicting and conflicted beliefs on the matter. His answer: "I think Hopkins was wrong." And he says that he thinks Hopkins came to see that he had been wrong... but there it is, an interpretation based on the author's desires. I don't think that this is a bad thing. But it hints at a different kind of novel, a more novelistic novel, and one that I would actually rather read. (Though as I said, Exiles is a good way to learn about Hopkins' life.)

But who in their right mind would feel able to write something like "The Death of Virgil" about Hopkins? The problem for anyone who would write a novel about Hopkins is that he is "Hopkins noster." He is one of those people who can go from historical character to beloved friend and guide once you make his acquaintance. I think of him still as Father Hopkins. And as attractive as a more interior novel about Hopkins would be to me, I think that I would be overcome by shyness and protectiveness, just as I would if someone wrote such a novel about one of my friends. And so Exiles succeeds as a biography. It is the best introduction to Hopkins' life for someone who has been dazzled or bewildered by his poetry, while knowing relatively little about him. Hansen says that he wrote the book with a non-Catholic audience in mind, and non-Catholics have given it some of the most positive reviews I've read.

I actually read Exiles at the worst possible time: just a few weeks after I had turned in my senior thesis on Hopkins. Hansen explains the style of his book like this: "[F]or those familiar with Hopkins, I scattered lines from his poetry, letters, and journals throughout the book as a sort of treasure hunt, while hoping that my own prose would provide the gingerbread base for his candies." These scattered lines are indeed as pervasive as gumdrops on a gingerbread house. And I was too familiar with Hopkins, having immersed myself (and nearly capsized myself like the Deutschland) in the same sources that Hansen consulted. It was too much. I could see every borrowing with my research-crazed x-ray vision. My knowledge of these "scattered lines" suggested some fascinating possibilities, though. The landscapes that Hopkins sees are described in his own words - but so are the landscapes that the nuns see. Sister Henrica writes a poem of her own for Mother Superior, and it's dreadful, treacly stuff - but later Hansen puts one of Hopkins' aesthetic judgments in her mouth:
Under each curl [of wave] shone a bright juice of beautiful green. Sister Barbara asked Sister Henrica how she would describe that color, and she gave it thorough consideration before saying, "Chrysoprase."
Sister Norberta scowled. "What on earth is that?"
Sister Henrica gently told her, "A mineral used for gems. The green of leeks mixed with gold."
Even though Sister Henrica is no poet, she sees exactly what Hopkins sees. Why? This is just one of the many subtle mysteries of Exiles, which are also the mysteries of our still triumphantly mysterious Hopkins.

Learn More:

NPR interview (via America)

Image interview with Paul Mariani, Catholic Hopkins scholar and friend of Ron Hansen whose biography of Hopkins will be published this October.

Reviews of Exiles:

A tortured Victorian and his art, reimagined (

God's cold, dark waters (Los Angeles Times)

A novel reason for rapture (Washington Post)


Santiago said...

This is very good. You should send it to a magazine -- send it to First Things for a daily article.

Anonymous said...

Located in the South of Morocco, it sits on the edge of the Atlas Mountains, where the land shades away into the Sahara desert.. [url=]cabas vanessa bruno[/url] Why?If you change it, people have to search for stuff, meaning they walk more and see things other than what they just intended to buy. It is their lake.. But this is actually the question does it focus on each and every fungus sufferer? Does it have a similar impact on everyone? I say that it help for most of us.
When such a buying panic hits, the fastest way to get money to work is to buy stock index futures, which are also nice if you can't find any particular stocks worth buying. [url=]canada goose parka[/url] Many of us will find this tea is amazing for hydration and is a cooling tea with no caffeine. [url=]canada goose sale[/url]
[url=]canada goose toronto factory[/url] hxjqwang posted blog postsIs the higher education a good investment?College is not necessary for all the youngSlow down the Pace to learn more about each other1 minute agoPono Kealoha posted a blog postSafeway busts through ancient Hawaiian burials and children bones for 67,000 sq ft superstore in Wailuku, Maui May 21, 2012 class="rich-detail">Safeway busts through ancient Hawaiian burials and children's bones for 67,000 sq ft superstore in Wailuku, Maui The Big Red S strikes again! Credited with some blatant inhumane acts in 2012 such as placing a child in protective services to arrest parents for failure to pay for a sandwich(Honolulu) and discrimination against women The giant is picking on the sacred dead of Hawaiians. [url=]beats by dre accessories cable[/url]

Anonymous said...

Odder sources of energy are under review. [url=]Doudoune Canada Goose[/url] Before beginning your search, it is best to assess your needs in a home. i've had to order a few meals by phone before, and I'm terrible at it. Right or wrong..
You may or may not meet the red-cockaded woodpecker, but you will certainly hear the raucous call of its pileated cousin. [url=]canada goose[/url] What exactly is a capsule wardrobe? A capsule wardrobe is a set of clothing, footwear and accessories that satisfy the style needs in one area of your life. [url=]canada goose for sale[/url]
[url=]canada goose jacket[/url] All these states in the usa include lots more old component, is mainly a very good overview throughout, and it also based from while using circumstance ones own little feet problems 5 moments per week, you are able to possibly be honestly content and articles to seek out typically the great layout not to mention fit through road boots or shoes geared to in in a spot among ones own lessons. [url=]refurbished beats pro headphones[/url]

Anonymous said...

Most of the campgrounds are located a short drive from Kaslo, British Columbia, or about 40 minutes from the much larger town of Nelson, British Columbia. [url=]Canada Goose Pas Cher[/url] The primary target audience consists of family back-yard farmers in rural and remote areas, who are then further segmented into North Vietnam and South Vietnam farmers, as poultry raising/farming practices vary by region due to weather and farming conditions. The Monaco performance was part of Chicago's 2008 World Tour, which takes them next to London in the United Kingdom (July 31), and from August to November across the United States and Canada. A very few insurances are worth buying, such as liability insurance for cars and real estate.
LONDON (Reuters) - Jimmy Savile, the late BBC TV star at the centre of a child sex scandal that has shaken Britain's state-funded broadcaster, may have abused up to 25 victims some as young as 13 over four decades, police said on Tuesday. [url=]canada goose toronto[/url] Certain superior kinds of wood varnish formulations deliver superior protection against heat, scratches and water. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url]
[url=]canada goose[/url] I haven't been able to achieve the phenomenal 84+ mpg that Wayne Gerdes and Ford did in driving 1440+ miles on one tank, but I've been able to average a respectable 41 mpg or so over the last 6 days / 175 miles, which means I still have 3/4 of a tank left. [url=]beats by dre pro fake or real[/url]

Anonymous said...

The eastern shores of Ellesmere, Devon, and Baffin islands, which are made up of ancient crystalline rocks, are deeply indented by fjords, have rocky cliffs, and are difficult to reach. [url=]cabas vanessa bruno[/url] After antiobiotics, topicals even injections I was prescribed Accutane. Her son got up all excited asking me how I did that. The street in which his mother resides bears a very bad name and is the resort of prostitutes, and there's several 'brothels' there.
This gives us a supply of oil not imported from other countries. [url=]canada goose jackets[/url] Reattach water lines. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url]
[url=]canada goose down jackets[/url] These days, however, shoes are rather less of a position symbol, go underground the whole enchilada demolition of the approach; also regard incline additional willingly available, with a greater range of supplementary fun, fashionable, well-formed and option styles!The Good, the best also the dynamite - discrepant Types of attractive cusp ShoesHigh prong shoes show up mastery a deviation of styles, from gun toe exemplary extent shoes, sling-back peerless extremity shoes or bait chopper priceless limitation shoes. [url=]limited edition kobe bryant beats by dre[/url]

Anonymous said...

Canary yellow, purple, black, opaque white or "milk," opaque green and cobalt blue, for example, are less common colors of Depression glass that are usually more expensive and highly sought after by collectors. [url=]Canada Goose Pas Cher[/url] Click on banner links to go to our other free gracetoday Christian sites. We live in the country, and there is a stream not too far from our house where the dogs loved to wade. It was an easy way to get big quick, to diversify holdings, eliminate competition, or even to outsource tasks such as research and development..
buy theirs.. [url=]canada goose parka[/url] I had a close companion, a cousin, that went all the way with Vaselined wings and a black leather jacket. [url=]canada goose whistler parka[/url]
[url=]canada goose on sale[/url] In our Wholesale Christian Louboutin Red Satin Anemone Pump Christian Louboutin Suede Fringe Pump Black online shop, you can pick up Christian Louboutin Sandals CLB188A and Christian Louboutin SO PRIVATE 120MM with 50% off, come on! Our extensive variety of sports Christian Louboutin maralena 140mm is available in many different designs and attractive colors. [url=]buy beats by dre in new york[/url]

Anonymous said...

Oh my my. [url=]canada goose parka sale[/url] For those non-Scouters out there, Scouts was started in 1907 by a man named Lord Baden Powell. Elk Prairie to Fern Canyon and Gold Bluffs Beach via the James Irvine Trail :: Orick, CAThis pleasant hike leads through a coast redwood forest and a fern-decked canyon to an inviting northern California beach. Be sure to climb the hill that rises up at the hike's halfway point for a panoramic view of the marshes and ponĂ¢€¦.
The cunningham is an extremely important control as it adjusts the tension of your luff and opens and closes the top of the leech.. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url] One of the main features when you are looking out for the Bridal salwar kameez is exclusiveness which can only be visible if you use material like satin that makes overall appearance appear glossy. [url=]canada goose whistler parka[/url]
[url=]canada goose down jackets[/url] I haven't met Logan but I can tell for sure these photos are overflowing with personality - you captured Becca's excitement for life and enthusiasm so well! I really enjoyed all of the photos where you caught Becca and Logan laughing - they just look like they were having such a good time together. [url=]beats by dre tour fake or real[/url]

Anonymous said...

Second, to be sure the audience understood that you get Eddie and you get something different, too. [url=]Canada Goose[/url] The Congress shall have Power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attainted. Second, find a comrade in comedy. This allows them to leap froward.
A highly varied shoreline and many marshy coves provide a haven for all sorts of waterfowl and wetland plants. [url=]canada goose[/url] His farmhouse was reportedly full of trophies for marksmanship.[3] It was during the Winter War (1939-1940), between Finland and the Soviet Union, that he began his duty as a sniper and fought for the Finnish Army against the Red Army.. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url]
[url=]canada goose down jackets[/url] We get most of our seasonal fruit in the country, but in between, a few good sources at the market are key; especially at this time of year, where it's summer just about everywhere else - it's hard to resist the taste of a good melon, cherry or pear when it's been so long. [url=]beats by dr dre kobe edition[/url]

Anonymous said...

You can buy this superb new apartment in Lanzarote for just 200,000 euro, and enjoy holidays in the sun. [url=]canada goose sale[/url] It is located at the end of the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf. She answered that we are not to far away from the falls and we could go there if I would like to. I for one am getting sick and tired of the goose-stepping cadre of the Grand Old Party.
Agriculture Minister John MacDonell unveiled the FarmNEXT program at the Federation of Agriculture meeting in Truro on Thursday, November 24, 2011. [url=]canada goose jackets[/url] He linked a modified 26-inch color domestic TV to a real-time transaction processing computer through a domestic phone line. [url=]canada goose parka sale[/url]
[url=]canada goose jacket[/url] They will be the biggest icons." Even although Louboutin faced appreciably opposition pursuing his choice to depart college so early, he promises that his resolve was strengthened best after observing an job interview on television set with Sophia Loren by which she introduced her sister, stating she experienced to depart college when she was only twelve but when she turned fifty she obtained her degree. [url=]beats by dre kids[/url]

Anonymous said...

Despite this large size, brown bears are extremely agile and fast, reaching speeds of 35 to 40 mph.. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url] There are many people that are wearing the same cloths but have different colors and different shapes on them. (It is said that Edward and his friend Charles Bunbury, tossed a coin to decide on who should have the honour of naming the race. Feb 7 09:54 AMIt's rather odd that Mr.
When it is sold as meat, often in good butchers and game shops, it is sold as a brace (a male and female bird together) and they are often hung to enhance their 'gamey' flavour.. [url=]canada goose outlet[/url] While jettisoning its failed apparel line, Airwalk began to produce its first casual and active casual shoes. [url=]canada goose sale[/url]
[url=]canada goose toronto factory[/url] This is the fact that a primary reason it is the fact an absolute must have Louis Vuitton Speedy to learn more about steer clear crystal clear absent form particular toenail fungus remedies that are by no means efficient because going to be the a little longer a lot of these remedies are which they can use,the more down and dirty going to be the infection is the fact that in all likelihood to keep in mind Consequently, instead to do with compensating a period of time everywhere over the remedies which are just do not put together to explore treat toenail fungus,element tends to be that recommended to explore want to buy Zetaclear and keep using aspect in accordance to the a good suggestion dosage thus as to learn more about Coach Diaper Bag achieve the objective having to do with healthy, fungus-free nails. [url=]50 cent wearing beats by dre[/url]